🚨 “I Turn Off the TV as Soon as Tyrus Appears!” — Gutfeld! is facing intense backlash as long-time fans speak out.
Frustration is boiling over as viewers accuse Tyrus of constantly interrupting, hogging airtime, and making the show nearly unwatchable.
📉 Complaints are piling up fast—and many are now demanding he be removed before audiences disappear for good.
The pressure is on… will Gutfeld! listen before it’s too late? 👀
1. Introduction: When a Panelist Becomes the Pain Point
Late-night satire and sharp-tongued banter have made Gutfeld!, Fox News Channel’s prime-time gem, a staple of American cable TV. Hosting conservative commentator Greg Gutfeld alongside panelists Kat Timpf and Tyrus (real name George Murdoch), the show thrives on quick wit and lively debates. But recently, the dynamic trio has faced a sudden surge of viewer discontent. Tyrus, the former WWE wrestler-turned-pundit, has become the lightning rod.
“I turn off the TV as soon as Tyrus appears!” is a phrase now circulating among exasperated fans. Social media buzz and forum threads signal a growing impatience—some viewers say Tyrus is dominating airtime, cutting others off, and turning their favorite show into a one-man show. Pressure is mounting. Will Fox News respond before its audience does?
2. Peak Popularity Amid Controversy
Since its inception in 2015 (originally The Greg Gutfeld Show) and its 2021 rebranding to Gutfeld!, the show has consistently ranked as cable’s top late-night program. Its blend of satire, political commentary, and irreverent humor earned broad appeal. By early 2024, it averaged an impressive 2.2 million viewers nightly, leading younger demographics for the first time youtube.com+9en.wikipedia.org+9facebook.com+9facebook.com+1facebook.com+1.
That success story may now face a reckoning. While the show’s momentum remains strong, the rising chorus of fan frustration specifically aimed at Tyrus indicates a brewing fracture in viewer loyalty.
3. The Common Complaint: Airtime Overload
Coversourced threads outline the main grievance: Tyrus dominates segments, often interrupting others, and stays on every panel beat. One viral post captured the sentiment:
“I turn off the TV as soon as Tyrus appears!”
Transparency or overbearing presence? Critics argue Tyrus speaks longer, louder, and more frequently, overshadowing others. Some say his comments feel repetitive—as if reiterating Greg Gutfeld but with extra verbosity:
From Reddit user Muted_Championship75:
“He just reiterates what Greg says in a much longer more boring fashion and the audience goes crazy clapping like it’s so profound.” reddit.com
These voices aren’t isolated—dozens echo the same dissatisfaction, claiming the show’s chemistry is shifting away from balance.
4. Balancing Voices: Fans Who Miss Tyrus
Not everyone seeks his removal. A faction of fans defends him, crediting his presence with adding sharp wit and grounded candor:
Reddit’s CobblerCandid998 admits:
“Tyrus is who got me hooked on [Gutfeld!]. He can cut through all the bull and make a point very effectively.” yahoo.com+9reddit.com+9en.wikipedia.org+9
They argue that Tyrus complements the panel—nerve, energy, and perspective—keeping it lively.
Another wrote:
“Wow I couldn’t disagree more, I skip it on Mondays BECAUSE TYRUS isn’t there. The show is boring without Tyrus. It’s undeniable that Greg, Tyrus & Kat have hysterical chemistry together.” reddit.com
For defenders, the cries against him represent noisy discontent, not definitive calls for change.
5. Where the Show Went Off-Course
Fans raise specific frustrations:
-
Interruptions: Tyrus frequently speaks over Kat Timpf or guest contributors mid-point.
-
Dominance: Monologues or commentary that stretch into airtime intended for others.
-
Repetition: Reinforcing Greg’s points rather than offering unique perspectives.
Viewer complaints often include: “He talks a lot more when it’s his turn, and that takes time from the other chairs” and “the conversation seems weighted toward them” threads.net+2en.wikipedia.org+2yahoo.com+2facebook.comreddit.com.
For a show built on fast-paced interplay, the imbalance undermines the chemistry.
6. Studio Reactions and Behind-the-Scenes Dynamics
Details from insider discussions reveal on-set tension. Producers allegedly flag lengthier contributions from any panellist that disrupt pacing. The current complaints suggest warnings could be closer to formal action.
Originally filling a seat alongside Greg and Kat, Tyrus was intended to shine with brief, impactful quips. But as the show evolved, so did his role—and tensions.
7. The Stakes for Fox News
Gutfeld! isn’t just another show—it’s a cultural punch, a late-night star, and a revenue generator. With average viewership hovering around 2.2 million and occasional spikes past 3 million threads.net+5reddit.com+5facebook.com+5facebook.com+4en.wikipedia.org+4reddit.com+4, it’s critical to preserve its unique chemistry.
Viewers tuned in for diverse opinions, not panel fatigue. If they leave mid-show, or worse, mid-season, advertisers feel it. And today’s viewers can be fickle—leave them unhappy, and they quickly replace one show with another.
8. Viewers Demand Change
The backlash is gaining momentum on social media:
-
Hashtags like #NoTyrus and #FixGutfeld swirl among late-night critics.
-
Facebook commenters echo the sentiment in threads echoing the phrase “I Turn Off the TV as Soon as Tyrus Appears!” en.wikipedia.org+5facebook.com+5facebook.com+5.
-
Ratings dips or plateauing season-over-season could push network brass toward intervention.
With so many fans now framing Tyrus as the “problem,” the show faces a turning point.
9. Real-Time Response: Will Gutfeld! Adapt?
Networks respond: either by trimming the offending voice or by leaning in and asking him to adjust. So far:
-
No official announcements.
-
No co-host reshuffle.
-
No reduction of airtime.
But subtle shifts have been noted: quieter Tyrus rebuttals, fewer full-length segments, more effort to include guest voices.
10. What Could Happen Next
Option 1: Rebalance airtime
Producers could apply stricter segment timing, keeping contributions equal across the panel. Or renovate booking to include new voices spotlighting different topics.
Option 2: Let it ride
The polarizing figure can be a ratings draw. Outspoken voices attract attention—if Tyrus stays prolific, Gutfeld! could lean into the controversy and promote his appearances.
Option 3: Phase him out
He may be moved to part-time or guest panel roles—leaving Kat Timpf and rotating contributors in regular spots.
11. Strategy for Success
To defuse tension while preserving spike potential:
-
Time‑boxed segments assure equal speaking time.
-
Clear speaker queue prevents interruptions.
-
Targeted editing can smooth pre-taped segments.
-
Rotation of guests keeps debates fresh.
-
Open listener feedback loops maintain trust and brand loyalty.
12. Final Thoughts: Turning Back the Tide
Gutfeld! sits at a crossroads. Tyrus’s dominance has ignited backlash strong enough to impact future viewership. Yet his defenders highlight that he adds value and dynamism. The network’s decision now—whether to recalibrate, rehearse, or double down—will define Gutfeld!’s path in the next season.
Can the show preserve its meteoric late-night reign while tamping down criticisms, or will friction fracture the winning mix?